Amaretto 5LB vs 2LB: Which Bulk Size Is Right for You
By Stone Street Coffee | Published: 2026-10-24
Category: Buying Guides
Compare Stone Street Coffee's Amaretto 5LB and 2LB bags to decide which bulk size fits your coffee consumption, storage space, and budget.
Quick answer
Choose the 5LB bag if you drink at least two cups daily or need to stock an office kitchen; pick the 2LB bag for occasional use, tight counter space, or first-time sampling.
Cost per pound and budget fit
The 5LB bag costs $62.42 (about $12.48 per pound), while the 2LB bag costs $23.40 (about $11.70 per pound). At first glance the smaller bag appears cheaper per pound, but the 5LB bag offers a lower total cost per cup if you drink coffee regularly. The 2LB bag's higher per-pound price is offset by a lower upfront investment, making it easier to try the flavor without committing to a large quantity.
If you are budget-conscious and drink coffee daily, the 5LB bag saves you roughly $0.78 per pound compared to buying two 2LB bags. However, if you are unsure about the amaretto flavor or have limited pantry space, the 2LB bag is a safer starting point.
Storage and freshness trade-offs
Amaretto coffee is a medium roast with flavor strength options, and its almond sweetness is best enjoyed fresh. A 5LB bag will last a single drinker about 40–50 days (assuming 2 cups per day). To preserve flavor, store the beans in an airtight container away from light and heat. If you lack a large airtight container or a cool, dark cabinet, the 2LB bag may be more practical.
For office use, the 5LB bag is ideal because multiple people will finish it before staleness sets in. For a home with one or two coffee drinkers, the 2LB bag ensures you always brew fresh coffee without worrying about flavor degradation.
How to decide: 5LB or 2LB?
- Daily consumption: If you drink 2 or more cups per day, the 5LB bag is cost-effective and will be used before freshness fades.
- Occasional or first-time buyer: If you drink coffee only a few times a week or want to try the amaretto flavor, start with the 2LB bag. You can always reorder the 5LB later if you love it.
- Storage space: If your pantry or counter is tight, the 2LB bag fits easily. The 5LB bag requires a larger airtight container and a cool, dark spot. Measure your storage area before choosing the larger bag.
- Office or shared kitchen: The 5LB bag is the better choice for an office or shared space where multiple people brew from the same supply.
Amaretto bag options at a glance
- Amaretto 5LB: The 5LB bag is a medium roast with multiple flavor strength options, offering a rich almond note inspired by classic Italian amaretto liquor. Larger households or offices can adjust the flavor strength to suit different palates while enjoying a consistent supply.
Amaretto 5LB - Amaretto 2LB: The 2LB bag shares the same medium roast and flavor strength options, making it a convenient size for sampling or smaller households. You get the same flavor flexibility without committing to a 5-pound quantity, which helps maintain freshness if you drink less coffee.
Amaretto 2LB
Which size fits you?
Best for
- Daily drinkers who want the lowest cost per cup
- Offices or shared kitchens with multiple coffee drinkers
Not for
- Occasional coffee drinkers who want maximum freshness
- First-time buyers unsure about the amaretto flavor
