Colombian Supremo 2LB vs Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB
By Stone Street Coffee | Published: 2026-11-02
Category: Comparisons
Compare Colombian Supremo 2LB and Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB on taste, body, and price to decide which single origin coffee to buy for your daily cup.
Quick answer
Choose Colombian Supremo 2LB if you want a clean, higher-acidity cup with caramel and chocolate notes for everyday drinking. Pick Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB if you prefer a creamier, sweeter light roast with milk chocolate and citrus and want the lower catalog price.
Flavor and body: clean and bright vs creamy and sweet
The Colombian Supremo taste leans on a solid body with higher acidity and a clean finish, plus notes of caramel and chocolate. That structure makes it forgiving across brew methods and easy to drink without much thought.
Tarrazu coffee flavor here is creamy and sweet, with bright acidity and notes of milk chocolate and citrus. The citrus note is the clearest separator: it adds a lift that the Colombian cup does not emphasize.
Roast level and what it means for your brew
Both are light roasts, so neither is built for a dark, smoky profile. The Costa Rica Tarrazu is explicitly described as a light roast; the Colombian Supremo is listed as South American Light. If you usually add milk or sugar, the Colombian's caramel-chocolate notes may hold up more predictably, while the Tarrazu's citrus can get lost behind dairy.
Price and value at the 2LB size
At catalog prices, Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB is USD 23.49 (comparison price USD 38.50) and Colombian Supremo 2LB is USD 25.20 (comparison price USD 36.00). The Tarrazu is the lower-priced bag today, but the gap is small enough that flavor should decide first. Both come in 2LB bags with a grind option, so you can order pre-ground or whole bean.
Sourcing story and what it does not tell you
The Costa Rica Tarrazu comes from a cooperative of farmers around the Tarrazu region, and many of those farmers produce only 10 bags of green coffee per year. That is a meaningful detail about scale, not a guarantee of a specific cup score. The Colombian Supremo is described as sourced straight from the source with an 18 screen and blue-green beans, which speaks to bean size and appearance rather than roast date or brew method. Neither listing supplies roast date, altitude, or process, so treat those as open questions if they matter to you.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Flavor priority: If you want creamy sweetness with citrus, buy Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB. If you want a clean, higher-acidity cup with caramel and chocolate, buy Colombian Supremo 2LB.
- Brewing with milk or sugar: The Colombian's caramel-chocolate notes are more likely to survive added milk; the Tarrazu's citrus can be muted. Choose Colombian Supremo if you regularly drink lattes or sweetened coffee.
- Price check: Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB is USD 23.49 versus USD 25.20 for Colombian Supremo 2LB at catalog prices. If the difference is not meaningful to you, decide on flavor; if it is, the Tarrazu is the lower-cost bag today. Prices can change, so confirm the current price before ordering.
- Grind option: Both bags offer a grind selection. Choose whole bean if you grind at home; choose a grind matched to your brewer if you do not.
Product facts
- Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB: Light roast with a creamy body, bright acidity, and notes of milk chocolate and citrus. If you want a sweeter, creamier cup with a citrus lift, this is the closer match.
Costa Rica Tarrazu 2LB - Colombian Supremo 2LB: South American Light roast with higher acidity, a clean finish, and notes of caramel and chocolate. This profile suits drinkers who want a clean, structured everyday cup rather than a creamy one.
Colombian Supremo 2LB
Which single origin coffee should you buy?
Best for
- Drinkers who want a creamy, sweet light roast with milk chocolate and citrus notes
- Shoppers who want the lower-priced 2LB bag at catalog prices
- Those who prefer a cooperative-sourced Costa Rican coffee
Not for
- Drinkers who want a clean, higher-acidity cup with caramel and chocolate
- People who regularly add milk and want the coffee notes to stay prominent
- Shoppers who need roast date or process details before buying
